What is it, how is it reproduced and developed, and what was its historical origin. Thompson this book has a clumsy title, but it is one which meets its purpose. Thompson s opus the making of the english working class. For a discussion of class ashistory, more firmly based within the sociological discipline, see s. Thompson famously rejected an analysis that addressed class as a. Thompson in the making of the english working class 1961 and an important essay, the moral economy of the english crowd in the eighteenth century, originally published in past and present in 1971 and included in customs in common. The moral economy of the english crowd in the eighteenth century 1971 chapter. He claims in the preface that in the years between 1780 and 1832 most english working people came to feel an identity of interests as between themselves, and as against other men whose interests are different from. In class society mens consciousness of social reality, when viewed from the standpoint of historical effectiveness, takes its form from the class structure of that society. Making, because it is a study in an active process, which owes as much to agency as to conditioning. The making of the english working class 1963 by edward p. The concept of moral economy was extensively developed by e.
A life of struggle francois jarrige a great historian of the english working class, a major intellectual figure in debates surrounding marxism in the years 19601970, and an antinuclear activist who initiated an environmentalist critique of capitalismsuch were the many faces of edward palmer. Thompson submitted by spassmaschine on apr 5 2011 07. The english proletariat emerged in the nineteenth century as a class distinguished by an immovable corporate classconsciousness and almost no hegemonic ideology. This short essay was written in 2012, during the second year of my. As one of the most important subjects in social history, class has been analysed in various ways. Following the groups ideas, thompson showed that the role of class consciousness to the development of social classes was anything but trivial. In marxs system, classconsciousness is a concept embodying the notion of true, that is, nonideological knowledge1. I i i i i i i the formation of the english working class vol. It was published in 1963 revised 1968 by victor gollancz ltd, and later republished by pelican, becoming an early open university set book.
The making of the english working class kindle edition. Apr 30, 2012 ep thompson the making of the english working class fully downloadable pdf version here. Thompson s final chapter on class consciousness outlines the sort of ideological manifestations we would expect from the early english industrial system. The making of the english working class by ep thompson 1963.
There have been numerous marxist studies of the working class, particularly by historians and sociologists, that describe important aspects of their. Edward palmer thompson, the greatest marxist historian of the english speaking world, died in august of 1993. After all, in almost pages he covers so much ground, in such great detail, that it feels inappropriate to even attempt to mention an section for fear of glossing over something equally important elsewhere. This emphasis on working class self activity was not merely an. Thompsons the making of the english working class is the obligatory.
Dominic alexander defends e p thompson s the making of the english working class one the most debated and influential of all the books produced by british marxist historians. Class consciousness by georg lukacs 1920 class struggle. Tyson tirta 0 comments the concept of class and class consciousness has had a significant role in english history. Nov 01, 2018 his work on the english labor class, allows for a better understanding of the marxist project, and how understanding class consciousness can lead to revolution. This paradox is the most important single fact about the english working class. The making of the english working class edward palmer. He is probably best known today for his historical work on the radical movements in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, in particular the making of the english working class 1963.
He also published influential biographies of william morris 1955 and posthumously william blake 1993 and was a. The making of the english working class has doubtless continued to be studied by academics and teachers since those days, but ep thompson who was a considerable personal force and a fierce debater died in 1993 and is no longer here to defend his views. E p thompson, the end of an episode, new society december 1979, p608. The mark of ep thompson s success is that his ideas of linking peace and human rights and of reuniting europe, which seemed so utopian in 1980, were on the lips of nearly every politician, east. Marx wrote that being shapes consciousness and this little quote perhaps explains the core idea of thompson s work. True professor thompson makes a todo about class consciousness nourishing the tree of liberty, but thats understandable in light of the subject, and besides for him class consciousness is not a determinist dogma, but the way in which experiences are handled in cultural terms. Proletarian and petit bourgeoisie 1912 the making of the english working class by ep thompson 1966 marxs use of class by bertell ollman 1968 class consciousness. Thompson, in full edward palmer thompson, born feb. Edward palmer thompson makes perhaps the best introduction to the realm of marxist history. Working class women have always worked, by the 50s. The making of the english working class kindle edition by. Commentators often describe thompsons central contribution as being the provision of a detailed understanding of class consciousness in. As one reads, however, all thoughts of sectarian vanish. In the end, it is the political context as much as the steamengine, which had most influence on the shaping consciousness and institutions of the working class 197.
Thompsons opus the making of the english working class. E p thompson this account of artisan and working class society in its formative years, 1780 to 1832, adds an important dimension to our understanding of the nineteenth century. Like any other relationship, it is a fluency which evades analysis if we attempt to stop it dead at any given moment and anatomise its structure. The class consciousness that thompson sees being created through the class struggle was not solely that of those in the most advanced. Ossowski, class structure in the social consciousness 1963. A historical phenomenon found in the raw material of experience and consciousnesswhen some men, as a result of their. Marx wrote about the theory in his book capital, volume 1, and again with his frequent collaborator, friedrich engels, in the impassioned treatise, manifesto of the communist party. Thus the stalinist ideology, which reduces the moral consciousness to class relativism, or to pavlovian behaviourism, forgets the creative spark without which man would not be man. Thompson defines class as an historical phenomenon, unifying a number of disparate and seemingly unconnected events, both in the raw material of experience and in consciousness. From class consciousness to culture, action, and social.
True professor thompson makes a todo about classconsciousness nourishing the tree of liberty, but thats understandable in light of the subject, and besides for him classconsciousness is not a determinist dogma, but the way in which experiences are handled in cultural terms. The making of the english working class book, 1964. Thompson, british social historian and political activist. In his classic study, the making of the english working class, ep thompson. The making of the english working class is a work of english social history, written by e. Thompsons social consciousness is evident in his poetry as early as 1940 when he was still at school and remained the dominant feature in all his writing until his death in 1993.
Thompson believed that the english working class was in the making by the 1830s, embedded by the 1890s, central by the 1940s and at the postindustrial crossroads by the 1960s. The first copy of the making of the english working class i read as an 18yearold is now in a sorry state. His the making of the english working class 1963 and other works heavily influenced postworld war ii historiography. Yet, camfield suggests that in thompsons schema, the relations of production are only the point of departure. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the making of the english working class. Thompson author of the making of the english working. Many marxist scholars, moreso even than marx himself, have this tendency to see class as a structural. The mark of ep thompsons success is that his ideas of linking peace and human rights and of reuniting europe, which seemed so utopian in 1980, were on the lips of nearly every politician, east.
By inhibiting the expression, at all levels of society, of this moral consciousness, stalinism leads men to the. Thompson uses the term working class rather than classes throughout, to emphasize the growth of a working class consciousness. You can support us by purchasing something through our amazonurl, thanks. The working class did not rise like the sun at an appointed time. Class consciousness refers to the awareness by a social or. He is probably best known today for his historical work on the british radical movements in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, in particular the making of the english working class 1963. In the end, it is the political context as much as the steamengine, which had most influence on the shaping consciousness. The origin of the black act new york, 1975, pp266, 265. In other words, thompson s version of working class consciousness invokes liberty and justice as much as it does deprivation and material factors. Class, thompson mtes, happens when some men, as a result of common experiences inherited or shared, feel and articulate he identity of their interests as between themselves, and as against other men whose interests are different from and usually opposed to theirs. Thompson brilliantly chronicled the ravages of early capitalism.
More than this, the notion of class entails the notion of historical relationship. But what is lacking for me is a theory of ideology that is more complex than mere false consciousness. Best known for his masterpiece the making of the english working class, thompson launched a current in marxist history which restored the exploited and oppressed to their rightful place as makers of history. E p thompson this account of artisan and workingclass society in its formative years, 1780 to 1832, adds an important dimension to our understanding of the nineteenth century. F or socialists, the class consciousness of the working class is oxygen.
Edward palmer thompson was an english historian, writer, socialist and peace campaigner. Yet, camfield suggests that in thompson s schema, the relations of production are only the point of departure. Consciousness of class arises in the same way in different times and places, but never in just the same way. My younger self loved this book because it opened a door on a. Apr 09, 2010 dominic alexander defends e p thompsons the making of the english working class one the most debated and influential of all the books produced by british marxist historians f or socialists, the class consciousness of the working class is oxygen. Ii ii ii ii ii ii ii the formation of the english working class vol. Thompson s monumental study of the making of the english working class, and the development of its consciousness, during its formative years of 1780 to 1832. Thompson participated in the founding of the british new left in the 1950s, and in the 1980s he became one of. Class consciousness and false consciousness are concepts introduced by karl marx that were later expanded by social theorists who came after him. My younger self loved this book because it opened a door on a world of courage and failure, loss and consciousness.
The making of the english working class, is not a conscious activity by any one group, least of all the working classes themselves. His major prose worksstudies of william morris and william blake, and a history of the english working classwere written out of a need to understand the big picture of political and literary history. Class consciousness, writes thompson, is the way in which these experiences, the experiences of being thrust through birth or an alternative form of involuntary entry into a class situation, are handled in. He is probably best known today for his historical work on the british radical movements in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, in particular the making of the english working class 1963 thompson published biographies of william morris 1955 and posthumously. Edward palmer thompson 3 february 1924 28 august 1993 was a british historian, writer, socialist and peace campaigner. Thompsons final chapter on class consciousness outlines the sort of ideological manifestations we would expect from the early english industrial system. I am repeating the suggestions i made in the preface to the making of the english working class, pp. How labor scholars missed the trump revolt the chronicle. Ep thompson the making of the english working class fully downloadable pdf version here. The making of the english working class1963 by edward p. Moral economy as a historical social concept blogger. The thing that most struck me about the book was thompsons emphasis on class consciousness, rather than simply class. Jun 06, 2016 consciousness of class arises in the same way in different times and places, but never in just the same way. Jul 07, 2008 the concept of moral economy was extensively developed by e.
Thompsons monumental study of the making of the english working class, and the development of its consciousness, during its formative years of 1780 to 1832. Classconsciousness is the way in which these experiences are handled in cultural terms. In part, thompsons book was an unconscious elegy for a way of life that we can. In the famous preface to the making of the english working class thompson outlined his view of class as.
The concept of class and classconsciousness has had a significant role in english history. P download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Penguin books a brief summary of the text we chose to focus on three of the essays in this volume, listed below with original publication dates. Iii iii iii iii iii iii iii the misery of the theory or a planetarium of errors a criticism of althussers thought schedule for a radical story the. The production of meaning is fundamentally behavioral and contextual. Class consciousness and false consciousness as defined by marx. The making of the english working class kindle edition by thompson, e. Class consciousness, writes thompson, is the way in which these. Thompson quotes author of the making of the english.
E p thompson and the making of the english working class. Ep thompson the making of the english working class. One vital question is what eventually happens to the workers in the declining trades. It concentrates on english artisan and working class society in its formative years 1780 to 1832. The making of the english working class, ep thompson. And because he was a leavisite as much as he was a marxist, he stitched his arguments, as far as he could, into the words of the people and their very english writers. Note the irony in thompson talking of a people being drugged when what characterises his historical. In other words, thompsons version of working class consciousness invokes liberty and justice as much as it does deprivation and material factors.
887 887 704 189 283 1565 720 131 1439 1403 519 54 617 1622 877 1665 1403 711 898 1679 1064 1148 1195 781 129 1069 238 1285 306 827 89 499 604 210 1232 1180 612 389 963 973 171 268 906 261 475 641 1273 847 324 24 498